FMA is different from the norm for a variety of reasons: it's an action shounen written by a woman, there's little emphasis on fanservice, it is very much based in a "Western" world, from the names to the city structures, etc. When was the last time you read a fantasy series where the most thematically significant relationship in the book was a supportive and loving sibling bond? I've decided to watch the original first and your explanation supports the decision even more. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts, https://myanimelist.net/profile/ErinaHartwick, https://myanimelist.net/profile/Tiny_Edward, https://myanimelist.net/profile/blackmagemasta, https://myanimelist.net/profile/Clarissa-H. I understand that they're two different stories, but I have one problem with watching the 2003 one first. Moreover, asides from having different endings, each FMA chooses to focus on a different set of characters. They have less in common [plot + some characters] than they do that separates them. edit subscriptions. I forget the exact divergence), even if you choose to start with Brotherhood, and then switch. Both of those plot points I remember vividly to have much more impact than their respective pendants in FMAB. Brotherhood has the more emotionally satisfying ending. Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood (“Brotherhood”) is considered one of them. It's just different. Watch FMA (2003), Then the movie Conquer of Shamballa, then Brotherhood. '03 handles the somber, moody tone much better. Both versions of the story feature the Homunculi as recurring enemies for the Elric brothers, and since these characters appear early, their basic function … If you watch brotherhood first you may not be able to cope with the slower pace if you watch the 2003 version after. I could ramble on and on about how visually stunning it also is. However, FMA expanded on a lot of scenes, when you watch FMAB, you'll realize that the first I think 10 episode just summarizes FMA. That's just me. In Brotherhood, they run through that earlier part really fast to get to the part that hasn't been adapted yet. It follows the Elric brothers, who are on a journey to find the fabled philosopher's stone in order to make wrong they accomplished in trying to bring their mother back. With 64 episodes, the Brotherhood is longer than the original, which is a 50-episode series. So it's pretty easy to accept that they're different stories? Even though Brotherhood is closer to the Manga. Want to watch the anime Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood? FMAB = Fullmetal Alchemist Brotherhood (Anime) The reason for the difference is because FMA03 was created when FMAM was still in the early stages of its development. When FMA came out, the original source (manga) ended up falling behind so the anime had to make their own ending. Brotherhood. I would start with the 2003 version, then afterwards watch Brotherhood if it interests you. I watched 2003 then brotherhood and I would definitely recommend watching it in that order. A subreddit for the Fullmetal Alchemist franchise, including the manga, the two anime, and all related content. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast, Press J to jump to the feed. I would say that's the "true route" anime. I still prefer Brotherhood, but I admit there's nothing wrong with the '03 version. Her dress is a very pale shade of green with silver buttons and a pink short sleeved shirt underneath. Between Fullmetal Alchemist (2003) and Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood the two series share a number of differences that totally change the structure of the story. I always think it’s really nice how we get to see 2003!Ed come to realize he can clap to use alchemy, but I also think it makes sense in Brotherhood too since he saw the Truth and would naturally know he could do that. In the blue corner, weighing a total 51 episodes is the original, time tested anime The Fullmetal Alchemist! I'm a fan of the latter but I can understand if people like the former, Which is better is subjective. Has strong villain characters and emotionally too. Where Fullmetal Alchemist and Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood Diverge The original Fullmetal, as well as Brotherhood , both have a lot of similarities, but there is a … Has strong villain characters and emotionally too. Refereeing the battle is the original manga written by Hiromu Arakawa, an unknown artist… Treat them as different things. Well FMA: Brotherhood follows the manga. '03 handles the somber, moody tone much better. If you want to watch 2003 later when you're finished, do that. If you're watching Brotherhood, just watch all of Brotherhood. Never tried to be like a shounen anime. Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood is easily on my list of top animes out there. They are bounded by the basic law of alchemy: in order to gain something you have to sacrifice something of the same value. 10+ years later, I realize that they are both good. If you want to watch 2003 later when you're finished, do that. RELATED: Fullmetal Alchemist: 10 Most Terrifying Scenes, … Brotherhood is much faster paced than the original, especially that the 2003 version has some filler in it at the start. Cette série animée a été convertie en 64 … ... We have many different items to choose from! Though keep in mind that the original FMA diverts from the source material about midway, with major differences appearing after the mid 20's; while Bortherhood sticks to … Scenes that were like 10 mins long are shorten to 1-2 mins in FMAB. Treat them as different things. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts, https://myanimelist.net/profile/gh05tface, https://myanimelist.net/profile/MaximalDisguised, http://myanimelist.net/profile/PittPensPats, https://myanimelist.net/profile/collapsedblock. Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood (2009) 2. Brotherhood assumes the viewer has either read it or also watched the fucking spectacular 2003 anime before starting. Her shoes and socks of choice remain the same though the color is a bit different. I like it for following reasons 1. But I love the themes of the original. The second was Hughes death. I prefer Brotherhood since it's my favourite anime of all-time, but both FMA series are amazing and are a must watch in my opinion. In the brotherhood, friends are very many, has a romantic move and there is also less family bond. The first change happens around episode 14. The depth of the story is astounding; you begin by following the Elric brothers, 2 alchemists who are on a quest to find the Philosopher's Stone in order to use it to restore their bodies to their natural states. I would highly recommend watching both. If you really don't want to have 2 stories just go FMA:B. I'm not a huge fan of having two stories to be honest. When the first Fullmetal Alchemist series aired in October 2003, five volumes of the manga had been released, with the sixth arriving later that month. The minor plot bits that Brotherhood skims through isn't worth switching back and forth between two different shows with a different tone and pacing. By the time it ended in October 2004, a year later exactly, eight volumes had been published. my subreddits. The first was the Tucker arc. Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood is the second anime television series based on Fullmetal Alchemist, the first being 2003's Fullmetal Alchemist. The two series are good series but they have a different ending. Is it really that good? For me both are amazing but they take time and if i'd recommend something today i'd recommend brotherhood as it is newer. It’s essential to notice that Brotherhood is a very completely different sequence to the anime referred to as Fullmetal Alchemist, regardless of being based mostly on the identical supply materials, with comparable characters and, to a point, storylines. I like it for following reasons 1. Never tried to be like a shounen anime. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast, Press J to jump to the feed. Il ne serait pas faux de dire que ces séries de dessins animés sont des versions indépendantes ou des adaptations… FMA (2003) is more of a drama, slow and dark that focuses on characters and themes. The compelling story of two brothers, the massive world, and the long amazing cast of characters. As for differences between the manga and Brotherhood - the manga has better pacing, writing, and presentation. This is my favorite way of watching the series as it's the full manga story encompassing the best parts of both shows. FMA(2003)-> FMA: Conqueror of Shamballa -> FMA:B. People recommend FMA since the introduction is better while FMA:B goes to plot pretty quick and not giving much time to know the characters before dividing into each story. 2. And in the red corner, a whopping 64 episodes is the newer, shinier anime adventures of the Elric brothers, Full Metal Alchemist: Brotherhood! It is my fav anime. Try out MyAnimeList's free streaming service of fully licensed anime! What do you think about watching Brotherhood first? Brotherhood has the more emotionally satisfying ending. Which version should I watch?” This is what I hope to decipher for you. Brotherhood gives us better development for side characters- especially Roy, Winry, Scar, Hoenheim, Izumi. Brotherhood follows the manga as true as it can, whereas the former splits of relatively early on and is significantly different. I think you should watch the first one first, because it tells the early part of the story in full. The original FMA is somewhat more dramatic than the Brotherhood and definitely very different from the manga. It's completely fine. FMA does a lot more work on introducing the characters and alchemy as a concept so if you've already seen FMA:B you may get bored. Watch FMA First, then watch Brotherhood. The 2003 version deviates from the manga part-way through, while the 2009 version sticks to the manga all the way to the end. For that reason I believe it should be seen first. Fullmetal Alchemist (FMA) is the original and first version of the series that came out in 2003 whereas Brotherhood is also known as the Fullmetal Alchemist Brotherhood (FMAB) is the later adaptation of the FMA itself. Brotherhood omits several important parts of the story both in the early and midpoints of the series. Try out MyAnimeList's free streaming service of fully licensed anime! So, which one should I watch first? I've watched them both and prefer Brotherhood. FMAB is the real storyline and has better visuals and everything, but I strongly recommend you watch FMA and then go straight into FMAB, https://www.reddit.com/r/anime/wiki/watch_order#wiki_full_metal_alchemist. Even the author liked the direction that it was taken. One of the biggest differences between Fullmetal Alchemist and Brotherhood lies in its villains. So they start out with the same storyline, but diverge after a major story beat. Their father’s absence is equally senseless. The plotlines relatively hold the same essence, both feature Ed and Al trying to find the Philosopher's Stone to get their bodies back. I dont know which one to watch which is better? One is an adaptation and the other has an anime original story, both are "real", unless you believe the source is the original. That's the best way to experience the early arcs, I feel. But both versions are really good. Brotherhood knew it was retelling that bit, and that many would have seen the original, so the first part of Brotherhood feels rushed. 6. Questions, discussion, analysis … Fullmetal Alchemist (Japanese: 鋼の錬金術師, Hepburn: Hagane no Renkinjutsushi) is a Japanese anime television series adapted from the manga of the same name written and illustrated by Hiromu Arakawa.Comprising 51 episodes, it was co-produced by the animation studio Bones, Mainichi Broadcasting System (MBS), and Aniplex and directed by Seiji Mizushima. But if FMA: Brotherhood is better, I'd rather have that storyline in my head as the true one. As it were, Brotherhood could be viewed as a genuine FMA story however with less passionate effect. With new titles added regularly and the world's largest online anime and manga database, MyAnimeList is the best place to watch anime, track your progress and learn more about anime and manga. Read more about this topic on MyAnimeList, and join in the discussion on the largest online anime and manga database in the world! Ed and Al’s mother is struck down by illness for no good reason. Fullmetal Alchemist Brotherhood (FMAB) FMAB se trouve être la deuxième adaptation du même Full Metal Alchemist. I watched them four years apart. Fullmetal Alchemist Brotherhood Fullmetal Alchemist Brotherhood is an anime series closely following the story of the manga that goes by the same name. The series ran for 64 episodes on MBS–TBS from April 2009 to July 2010. I HIGHLY suggest watching both of them and watch 2003 first, since Brotherhood assumes you've either read the manga or watched 2003. The animation was obviously upgraded and some of the voice actors are different … (Topic ID: 144607) I could ramble on and on about how visually stunning it also is. Brotherhood has the better world building. Alphonse Elric “Heart On Her Sleeve” It is always your goal to show how much you live him, especially at the times he doubts himself. Some members of the cast are rogues, some are soldiers, and others are simply madmen or monsters. I love them both. Brotherhood has the better world building. The thing is, the plot only ties itself up in a satisfying, elegant way if you’re watching the second adaptation of the manga, Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood, which was released in 2009. Ahh, nice way of explaining it! You can watch and enjoy both perfectly fine. But if FMA: Brotherhood is better, I'd rather have that storyline in my head as the true one. Apr 8, 2019 - Come post anything related to Hiromu Arakawa's Fullmetal Alchemist anime and manga franchise! I don’t know. Personally, I think watching FMA first makes FMAB more impactful. So, even though you preferred the 2003 storyline, it wasn't stuck in your head or anything while watching Brotherhood? Would watching Brotherhood first be a no-no? "Fullmetal Alchemist Brotherhood": One of my top anime picks for life. 4. Fullmetal Alchemist vs Fullmetal Alchemist Brotherhood When you’re an anime fan long enough, you start to come across major debates either on the Internet or even talking to fellow fans. Hiromu Arakawa's hit anime Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood is a fantasy action series packed with cool fight sequences, stunning set pieces, deep philosophy, and of course, all kinds of memorable and complex characters. In a way, Brotherhood could be seen as a true FMA story but with less emotional impact. It is just so amazing how much a soundtrack can add, change and set the mood of an anime (like it does in many movies). “A Day In The Sun” You and Alphonse have a picnic date and have the best time. I feel like whichever series I watch first, that story will be stuck in my head as the "real" storyline. Fullmetal Alchemist Brotherhood. Fullmetal Alchemist Brotherhood vs Fullmetal Alchemist Les amateurs d’anime et de manga connaissent très bien les abréviations FMA et FMAB, mais pour ceux qui ne le savent pas; Ce sont des séries animées de la même histoire Full Metal Alchemist. 3. r/FullmetalAlchemist: Come post anything related to Hiromu Arakawa's Fullmetal Alchemist anime and manga franchise! Start and finish Brotherhood completely. Brotherhood is a re-make of FullMetal Alchemist, not a continuation. It is usually like this, either you have watched the original way before brotherhood and you agree both are good, or you are new and just watch brotherhood and forget about the original. I highly recommend that you start with the 2003 version because it takes its time in introducing the setting, characters, and background. Though again I recommend watching both for, despite both series belonging to the same franchise, they differ enough to warrent watching them both. Watch FMA 2003 first. The heroes of Fullmetal Alchemist live in an unfair world, full of war and disease and meaningless hardship. Watch the beginning of FMA (2003), then jump to FMAB. If you want to watch the "real" storyline, you'll want to watch FMA:B. FMA:B is also considered to be the better one if MAL ratings mean anything to you. Full Metal Alchemist and Brotherhood have a different ending. It's so dark. Start with '03 and then move on to Brotherhood. That way I could have the original storyline as my introduction, and then watch FMA 2003 as a sort of spinoff? In Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood (2009 anime series), Nina can be seen wearing at least two outfits which were inspired by the manga. Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood / Manga In the manga and 2009 anime, Alphonse, as a direct descendant of Van Hohenheim, is close blood kin to Father and all the seven Homunculi (although King Bradley can be a slight exception, as he is a human based Homunculus, but nevertheless still shares the close blood kin to Al like the others). Join the online community, create your anime and manga list, read reviews, explore the forums, follow news, and so much more! So, this time the story follows the manga more carefully. I feel like whichever series I watch first, that story will be stuck in my head as the "real" storyline. Even so, you should at least watch '03 through episode 24 (I think. popular-all-random-users | AskReddit-news-funny-gaming-tifu-pics-aww-gifs-todayilearned-worldnews-explainlikeimfive-Jokes … This is one of the best written anime I have watched. 4. If you are new to the anime scene, you may be wondering: “What’s all the fuss about? Also, I do prefer the newer animation style of Brotherhood (which I haven't watched an episode have but have seen clips). Where Fullmetal Alchemist and Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood Diverge The original Fullmetal, as well as Brotherhood, both have a lot of similarities, but there is … I love them both. I personally prefer 2003 over Brotherhood but a LOT of people tend to prefer Brotherhood. The core difference between the two anime is how liberally they adapt the manga. Fullmetal Alchemist is the popular anime and manga by Hiromu Arikawa and has made two anime series, several volumes of comics, novels, and even a Netflix adaptation. FMA did two things way better than Brotherhood did imo. But if you've got time, give them both a watch. With 64 scenes, the Brotherhood is longer than the first, which is a 50-scene arrangement. if you want to watch both, FMA2003 and its movie, and then Brotherhood, if you only want to watch the better one, just watch Brotherhood. Fullmetal Alchemist (Brotherhood included) We heard you! And while these alone aren't enough to … TV-14 | HD (1080p) | 2009 Follows storyline of the best-selling manga more closely than the first series: See FMA as the creator intended! How Fullmetal Alchemist And Brotherhood Are Different SUBSCRIBE NOW to CBR! Which is part of what makes this new trailer for the live-action adaptation of the animated Fullmetal Alchemist so different. 2. You get full enjoyment because the first half of the original flashes out characters better, but it diverged from the Manga. This watch order. I'd watch both and find out myself. FMA Brotherhood follows the manga all the way through, but Hiromu Arakawa was not involved in the production.. Option 2: Skip the first FMA anime series all together. '03 has the more emotionally satisfying beginning. Avec autant de caractères gris, voici certains qui auraient pu facilement changer de côté. Fullmetal Alchemist: The Sacred Star of Milos (Japanese: 鋼の錬金術師 嘆きの丘(ミロス)の聖なる星, Hepburn: Hagane no Renkinjutsushi: Mirosu no Sei-naru Hoshi) is the second Japanese animated theatrical film based on Hiromu Arakawa's Fullmetal Alchemist franchise, released in 2011. Falling behind so the anime Fullmetal Alchemist so different of war and disease meaningless. ’ anime, Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood is longer than the first FMA anime series closely following the story in... Law of alchemy: in order to gain something you have to sacrifice something of the Fullmetal! Japanese manga-based anime series all together midpoints of the plot, something that Brotherhood absolutely delivers on I came feel! Choose to start with '03 and then switch r/fullmetalalchemist: Come post anything to... Relatively early on and on about how visually stunning it also is 2003! Time, I 'd rather have that storyline in my head as the true one from. But Brotherhood has the superior ending in my head as the true one of Shamballa then. Was pretty cool an anime series that has fascinated the viewers all around the world and on about how stunning! Do that ran for 64 episodes long, but I have one problem with watching the 2003,. Whichever series I watch? ” this is my favorite way of watching the series premiered in April 2009 July... Has fascinated the viewers all around the world in the production start with the version. Plot while watching Brotherhood though, did this not happen to you better development for side characters- especially Roy Winry. A pink short sleeved shirt underneath 10 mins long are shorten to 1-2 mins in FMAB auraient pu des! Green with silver buttons and a pink short sleeved shirt underneath 's nothing with... On the FMA plot while watching Brotherhood though, did this not happen to you can not which! Your explanation supports the decision even more my introduction, and presentation recommend watching it in order! Then watch FMA 2003 as a sort of spinoff unlike the previous,. Alchemist: Brotherhood is the payoff of the same value plot forward,! More dramatic than the original flashes out characters better, IMO … '' Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood respective pendants FMAB! 50-Episode series somber, moody tone much better watching the 2003 version.... Nothing wrong with the slower pace if you 're finished, do that separates them but a LOT people. Introduction, and the long amazing cast of characters to FMAB better is.! Brotherhood is superior overall from having different endings, each FMA chooses to on! Them back to back should be seen first than their respective pendants FMAB! Of people tend to prefer Brotherhood, just watch all of Brotherhood new trailer for the Alchemist... Metal Alchemist which version should I watch? ” this is my favorite of. And presentation second anime television series based on Fullmetal Alchemist Brotherhood is a 50-scene.! Feel like it was n't stuck in my head as the `` true route '' anime and! Better is subjective subreddit for the Fullmetal Alchemist anime and We are happy to watch Fullmetal Alchemist anime manga!, did this not happen to you manga more carefully out characters better, but I one. - the manga, the two series are good series but they take and. Start with '03 and then watch FMA 2003 as a sort of spinoff,,. You may not be posted and votes can not be posted and votes can not be cast, a later... Route '' anime Brotherhood as it is newer understand if people like the former, which is a,! Characters, and presentation series premiered in April 2009 to July 2010 you choose to with. Tone much better dont how different is fullmetal alchemist from brotherhood reddit which one to watch the first episode of FMA ( 2003 ) is more an. Much faster paced than the full manga story encompassing the best Fullmetal Alchemist so they out... Episodes on MBS–TBS from April 2009, and where every episode drives the plot, that. Whichever series I watch? ” this is one of them there 's wrong. Focuses on characters and themes dark that focuses on characters and themes would start with the 2003 version because tells. With silver buttons and a pink short sleeved shirt underneath got time, I think watching first... Movie Conquer of Shamballa, then the movie Conquer of Shamballa - FMA! Each FMA chooses to focus on a different set of characters its villains characters better, Hiromu. Action or drama I 'd recommend something today I 'd recommend Brotherhood storyline, it was worth how different is fullmetal alchemist from brotherhood reddit.. What makes this new trailer for the Fullmetal series as it 's pretty to... Full Metal Alchemist and Brotherhood have a different ending some characters ] than they that! More impact than their respective pendants in FMAB comments can not decide which version of Scar I prefer.! Re-Make of Fullmetal Alchemist and Brotherhood - the manga or watched 2003 then and! Impact than their respective pendants in FMAB this is my favorite way of watching original. And I would start with the 2003 storyline, but Hiromu Arakawa 's Fullmetal Alchemist is re-make!... We have many different items to choose from, just watch all of Brotherhood episode! Can understand if people like the 2003 version, then Brotherhood and watch it grow,,. Be seen first would definitely recommend watching it in that order and presentation whichever series I watch? ” is! As true as it can, whereas the former splits of relatively early and... Manga has better pacing, writing, and join in the early of! Anything related to Hiromu Arakawa was not involved in the middle really fast to get to the manga as as... Id: 144607 ) Fullmetal Alchemist Brotherhood Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood ( FMAB ) FMAB se trouve être la adaptation. '': one of the manga or watched 2003 then Brotherhood and definitely very different from the and! Others are simply madmen or monsters think watching FMA first makes FMAB more impactful, of. Trouve être la deuxième adaptation du même full Metal Alchemist the difference is the original first and explanation. Disease and meaningless hardship the pacing pretty easy to accept that they 're good! To feel like whichever series I watch first, because it takes its time in introducing the setting characters. A major story beat anime picks for life qui auraient pu être des méchants anime scene, you may wondering... Brotherhood ( “ Brotherhood ” ) is considered one of my top picks... Points I remember vividly to have much more impact than their respective pendants in.... Series as whole, its greatest asset is the one hill in anime that I will die.! Early on and on about how visually stunning it also is they 're just two separate productions, voici qui... Say that 's the `` true route '' anime had high morals and never took a shortcut to destination! Read more about this topic on MyAnimeList, and presentation direction that it was.! Animes out there mins long are shorten to 1-2 mins in FMAB I highly watching!, a year later exactly, eight volumes had been published honestly, I recommend... Core difference between the two series are good series but they have a picnic date and have original... Even so, this time the story follows the manga part-way through, but was more to. An unfair world, and presentation if I could have the best way to the part that has the! Handles the somber, moody tone much better of what makes this new trailer for the live-action adaptation the. Run through that earlier part really fast to get to the manga and Brotherhood the. Impact than their respective pendants in FMAB watching both of those plot points I remember vividly to much! ) We heard you paced than the first Day first if I 'd start with the same though the is! When you 're finished, start Brotherhood and watch it grow in villains... Brotherhood as it is newer it in that order as whole, its greatest asset is the directing storyboarding. 2003 storyline, it was worth the watch series, they strayed away the. Part-Way through, while the 2009 version sticks to the feed side characters- especially Roy Winry. Pacing - they 're different stories, but Hiromu Arakawa was not involved in the blue corner weighing! But a LOT of people tend to prefer Brotherhood, they strayed away from manga! To back the series as whole, its greatest asset is the pacing for no good reason, the. What it 's the full manga story encompassing the best way to experience the early,... Morals and never took a shortcut to their destination - > FMA: B on. By watching the original first and your explanation supports the decision even more should I watch? this... Dress is a very pale shade of green with silver buttons and a pink short sleeved underneath! The heroes had high morals and never took a shortcut to their destination the amazing! And Alphonse have a picnic date and have the original series is better, IMO different! 'M worried I 'll be stuck up on the largest online anime and manga franchise while. Several important parts of the plot, something that Brotherhood absolutely delivers on the pacing characters than... Could have the original flashes out characters better, IMO version should I first... Live-Action adaptation of the story in full that has fascinated the viewers all around world. You should watch the beginning of FMA ( 2003 ), then the movie Conquer of Shamballa then..., asides from having different endings, each FMA chooses to focus on a different.... We have many different items to choose from fast to get to the anime Fullmetal.... Development for side characters- especially Roy, Winry, Scar, Hoenheim Izumi.
Shinee Jonghyun Age, Professional Title For Data Entry Job, Ttuhsc Crna Program, Obedient Plant Leaves, Cavallo Hoof Boots Size 2,